You are falling into the same intellectual BS trap Democrats and Liberals continue to fall into.
People are openly saying why they voted the way they did and here you are, like every stupid Democrat for the last 30 years, trying to tell them why they voted they way they did without listening. What the logical outcome of a policy is has never mattered, ever, even long before Trump. The only thing that is ever mattered is what people believe and how they feel about a policy and a politician.
You think people act and vote with logic and reason, but they don't they never have, they never will. You don't even vote with logic and reason, you do what everyone does. You come to a decision based on instinct and emotion and then selectively find reasons and justifications to support you already chosen conclusion and reject the alternative.
People believe and feel like Trump is going to make their lives better. That's it, that's as far as it needs to go. Democrats need to learn to stfu about logic and reason and every other thing other than appealing to people on an emotional level because nothing else wins elections. Obama didn't win two terms based on logic and reason.
Logical arguments will never be as compelling as emotional ones.